| Year | Name | Hometown |
| 2022 | Mayadenise Gaskin Top 15 at Miss Teen USA | Tucson |
| 2021 | Mckenzi Lindhag | Peoria |
| 2020 | Molly Schwanz Top 16 at Miss Teen USA | Scottsdale |
| 2019 | Jordan Waller | Phoenix |
| 2018 | Macy Deak | Phoenix |
| 2017 | Karlina Riggs Top 15 at Miss Teen USA | Scottsdale |
| 2016 | Tristany Hightower | Paradise Valley |
| 2015 | Neda Danilovic Top 15 at Miss Teen USA | Phoenix |
| 2014 | Savannah Wix Top 15 at Miss Teen USA Also Miss Arizona USA 2019 | Paradise Valley |
| 2013 | Olivia Argue | Paradise Valley |
| 2012 | Alexa Zellers | Scottsdale |
| 2011 | Molly Argue | Paradise Valley |
| 2010 | Tori Vance | Ahwatukee |
| 2009 | Whitney Nelson | Ahwatukee |
| 2008 | Ashley Stainton Top 15 at Miss Teen USA | Ahwatukee |
| 2007 | Tiffany Martin | Phoenix |
| 2006 | Emerald Zellers Top 10 at Miss Teen USA | Scottsdale |
| 2005 | Elisa Soto | Mesa |
| 2004 | Allie Gilliland | Glendale |
| 2003 | Natalia Benenson | Phoenix |
| 2002 | Lynsie Ann Shackelford | Mesa |
| 2001 | Eva Marie St. Arnauld | Mesa |
| 2000 | Sarah Wilkins | Gilbert |
| 1999 | Danielle Demski Top 5 at Miss USA Also Miss Arizona USA 2004 | Chandler |
| 1998 | Kristy Kay Stover | Phoenix |
| 1997 | Julie Gulbrandsen | Gilbert |
| 1996 | Courtney Hamilton Top 6 at Miss Teen USA | Chandler |
| 1995 | Brandy Leigh Campbell | Tucson |
| 1994 | Mistie Kline | Phoenix |
| 1993 | Dannielle Normandin | Phoenix |
| 1992 | Heather Keckler Also Miss Arizona USA 2000 | Chandler |
| 1991 | Christine Ciulla | Phoenix |
| 1990 | Jeri-Lynn Beatty Semi-Finalist at Miss Teen USA | Glendale |
| 1989 | Leann Elston | Tucson |
| 1988 | Kristen Peterson | Tucson |
| 1987 | Julie Hodges Best State Costume at Miss Teen USA | Glendale |
| 1986 | Kristi Vanney Miss Photogenic at Miss Teen USA | Tempe |
| 1985 | Vanessa Steffens | Scottsdale |
| 1984 | Shawn Andrews | Mesa |
| 1983 | Kris Keim Also Miss Arizona USA 1988 | Scottsdale |
