| Year | Titleholder | Hometown |
| 2022 | Isabel Ticlo | Chandler |
| 2021 | Cassidy Jo Jacks | Mesa |
| 2020 | Yesenia Vidales Islas | Phoenix |
| 2019 | Savannah Wix Also Miss Arizona Teen USA 2014 | Paradise Valley |
| 2018 | Nicole Smith | Phoenix |
| 2017 | Tommy Lynn Calhoun | Tucson |
| 2016 | Chelsea Myers Top 15 at Miss USA | Chandler |
| 2015 | Maureen Montagne Top 15 at Miss USA | Tempe |
| 2014 | Jordan Wessel Top 20 at Miss USA | Phoenix |
| 2013 | Rachel Massie | Glendale |
| 2012 | Erika Lane Frantzve Kirk | Scottsdale |
| 2011 | Brittany Brannon Kennada Top 15 and Miss Photogenic at Miss USA | Paradise Valley |
| 2010 | Brittany Bell | Chandler |
| 2009 | Alicia Monique Blanco Second Runner up to Miss USA | Phoenix |
| 2008 | Kimberly Joiner | Gilbert |
| 2007 | Courtney Barnas Franco | Mesa |
| 2006 | Brenna Sakas Heater Top 15 at Miss USA | Chandler |
| 2005 | Mariana Loya | Gilbert |
| 2004 | Danielle Demski Top 15 at Miss USA Also Miss Arizona Teen USA 1999 | Chandler |
| 2003 | Nafeesa Deflorias | Phoenix |
| 2002 | Jennifer Lenz | Mesa |
| 2001 | Tasha Dixon | Phoenix |
| 2000 | Heather Keckler Also Miss Arizona Teen USA 1992 | Scottsdale |
| 1999 | Cara Jackson Miss Congeniality at Miss USA | Chandler |
| 1998 | Stacey Kole Top 10 at Miss USA | Tempe |
| 1997 | Jessica Nicely | Gilbert |
| 1996 | Christina Novak | Tempe |
| 1995 | Shara Riggs | Oro Valley |
| 1994 | Jennifer Tisdale | Mesa |
| 1993 | April Hettich | Scottsdale |
| 1992 | Dannis Shephard Top 11 at Miss USA | Mesa |
| 1991 | Maricarroll Verlinde Top 11 and Best State Costume at Miss USA | Tempe |
| 1990 | Leslie Leonard | Tempe |
| 1989 | LeeAnne Locken Top 10 at Miss USA | Apache Junction |
| 1988 | Kris Keim Also Miss Arizona Teen USA 1983 | Scottsdale |
| 1987 | Diane Martin Second Runner Up to Miss USA | Phoenix |
| 1986 | Jodi Armstrong | Phoenix |
| 1985 | Michelle Ducote Anglim Top 10 and Best State Costume at Miss USA | Tempe |
| 1984 | Daria Sparling Best State Costume at Miss USA | Tucson |
| 1983 | Sindy Hedden | Tucson |
| 1982 | Lori Hakola | Tucson |
| 1981 | Cassie Hill Top 12 at Miss USA | Phoenix |
| 1980 | Jineane Ford First runner up to Miss USA; Became Miss USA when Shawn Weatherly won Miss Universe | Gilbert |
| 1979 | Ana Rupert Top 12 at Miss USA | Scottsdale |
| 1978 | Jacque Crutchfield | Phoenix |
| 1977 | Toni Abranovic Top 12 at Miss USA | Scottsdale |
| 1976 | Curvey Walters | Phoenix |
| 1975 | Sanna Osgood | Scottsdale |
| 1974 | Carlys Peterson Top 12 at Miss USA | Phoenix |
| 1973 | Sherry Nix Third Runner Up to Miss USA | Phoenix |
| 1972 | Marcia Banks | Tempe |
| 1971 | Susanne Pottenger Second Runner Up to Miss USA | Tempe |
| 1970 | Alicia Lein | Mesa |
| 1969 | Ruth Hayes Third Runner Up to Miss USA | Tempe |
| 1968 | Shirley Sprague | Avondale |
| 1967 | Judianne Magnusson Top 15 at Miss USA | Mesa |
| 1966 | Roxanne Neeley Top 15 at Miss USA | Oro Valley |
| 1965 | Jane Nelson First Runner Up to Miss USA | Mesa |
| 1964 | Diane Reutter | Phoenix |
| 1963 | Diane McGarry Top 15 at Miss USA | Mesa |
| 1962 | Jerri Michaelson Top 15 at Miss USA | Paradise Valley |
| 1961 | Shyrle Owens Ortiz | Avondale |
| 1960 | Virginia Crook | Mesa |
| 1959 | Patricia Varga | Mesa |
| 1958 | Shirlee Fox | Avondale |
| 1956 | Maija Bertulson | Tucson |
| 1955 | Patti Marks | Phoenix |
| 1954 | Bonnie Johnson | Glendale |
| 1953 | Eleanor Ruth Cross | Chandler |
| 1952 | Charlene Hendricks | Tempe |
